Think about integration issues

When doing work on something that is supposed to be used by others, don’t forget to think about how it’s actually going to be used. Not only to think about it, but to actually try it out, to confirm that it works nicely when integrated, and that it’s easy to integrate it. And let’s not forget to document how to integrate it, and ideally to test it as well.

As an example, in Launchpad we use lazr-js for our Javascript infrastructure. We recently changed the way it’s integrated into Launchpad, giving it a proper setup.py file, so that we can generate an egg and depend on it through Buildout. The integration issue was of course taken into account there, making sure it was easy to build lazr-js both standalone, and when used in another project, like Launchpad. There was one command to build everything, which is simple enough. However, one thing wasn’t done. It wasn’t documented how you should use lazr-js in another project. Therefore, when people continued to develop lazr-js, adding more features, and making the build system more complicated, there wasn’t much thought about keeping it easy to build lazr-js in other projects. The build process became more complicated, multiple commands had to be executed. This is fine when building lazr-js by itself, since all you have to do is make build. However, when using lazr-js as an egg, you don’t have access the Makefile, which means that you have to duplicate the build steps. Therefore, having the build to be more than one command, makes it harder to use elsewhere. In fact, the build process of lazr-js changed so much, that we didn’t know anymore, how to properly use the latest version of lazr-js in Launchpad.

This is just one example of integrating external libraries. But the same is true for code internal to the project. When developing code that is to be used by multiple call sites, it’s important to think about how it’s actually going to be used. It’s easy to get carried away, developing a, what you think, really nice API. But then when people start to use it, it turns out that it’s not so nice.

What can be done to avoid integration issue? Ideally, you should document and test how the integration is supposed to work. By doing this, you get a feel of how to use the API. Doctests are actually quite nice for this purpose. If you manage to produce a readable doctest, it’s quite probable that your API is easy enough to use.

Sometimes adding tests for integration isn’t feasible. For example, in the case of lazr-js is not that easy. What I do when I develop on lazr-js is to have a throw-away Launchpad branch, where I use my lazr-js branch and manually make sure that it works nicely when integrated. Take a look at how it looks when integrated. What steps do you have to do to use it? Is that something that you will want to do for every call site? Are people likely to copy and paste an existing example to use your code? If the answer to the last question is yes, it’s not easy to use your code.

Add post to:   Delicious Reddit Slashdot Digg Technorati Google
Make comment

Pingbacks

27.06.2013 8:57 propecia @www.treintadetreinta.org
21.06.2013 10:03 rimonabantexcellence site title @www.rimonabantexcellence.com
Hello http://tillenius.me/blog/2009/12/11/think-about-integration-issues/

Comments

I like when you talk about this type of stuff in your blog. Perhaps could you continue this? Bobsweep reviews

I still think its really useful. I still really like your writing style. Keep up the great work. Bobsweep reviews

Required. 30 chars of fewer.

Required.